Too Intellectual

It’s wild to me that Bellow’s contemporaries criticized his writing as too intellectual. Of course it is quite intellectual (though perhaps not by a proper intellectual’s standards; proper intellectuals seem to be extremely specialized in what they talk about or else fixated on science fiction); but what other reason is there to read a book except for to get ideas and see a character wrestling with ideas?

I suppose I do get that Herzog, for example, is overtly concerned with ideas in a way that, say, The Iliad isn’t. But The Iliad would be a movie today. You can’t easily make a movie out of Herzog…. It would be more complicated to contrast Herzog (ideas) with say Molloy (anti-ideas), but I would say there is almost a Tragedy vs. Comedy type difference as opposed to an ideational one in that instance.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.